The hidden job market

How senior hiring is actually designed

From outside, a senior hire looks like an event: a role appears. From inside it is a process with several stages, most of which happen before anything is written down.

The sequence, as it usually runs

  • A pressure appears — a departure, a change in structure, a plan that the current team cannot deliver.
  • The pressure is discussed informally, often for weeks, before anybody calls it a role.
  • A budget is confirmed, which is the first moment the seat is genuinely real.
  • A brief takes shape in conversation, usually between two or three people.
  • Names are raised. Every senior hiring conversation includes this step and it is almost never recorded.
  • Only if that fails does the role become a specification, a search mandate, or an advert.

Why the design looks like this

Because senior hiring is expensive, political and personal. A chief hire that fails costs a year and damages whoever advocated for it, so the people involved reduce risk the way humans always do — by preferring somebody they or a trusted colleague can vouch for. The advert is not the beginning of the process. It is the point at which the low-risk options have been exhausted.

The advert is not the start of a senior hire. It is the admission that the names already raised did not work.

What this means for a candidate

The useful window opens at the pressure, not the advert. A departure, a restructure or a funding event tells you a conversation is beginning somewhere inside — weeks or months before a specification exists. Arriving then is a different act from applying: there is no queue to join, and being known is worth more than being qualified.

What it does not mean

That advertised roles are worthless — plenty of good roles are advertised, particularly in larger organisations with formal processes. It means that by the advert you are competing on a shortlist that partly formed before you arrived, and that the earlier window exists whether or not you use it.

Keep reading

Related

See it against your own companies

A short call, your target list, and an honest answer about whether this fits how you are running your search.