Recruiters and search firms

What a headhunter's call really means

An unexpected call from a search consultant is one of the few genuinely pleasant interruptions in an executive career. It is worth taking every time — and worth understanding, because not every call is about hiring you.

The three calls that sound identical

They want you for this seat

A specific brief, and you fit it. The consultant will move quickly and be concrete about the role.

They want names from you

A legitimate and constant part of the work. The tell is that the questions are about the market rather than about your plans.

They are mapping the market

Building a picture of who sits where, often before a mandate exists. Useful to be part of, and not a process you are in.

They are checking a competitor

You are being asked about a company, not about a role. Answer carefully; discretion here is noticed and remembered.

How to tell which one you are in

Ask two questions early and politely: is there a specific role, and where is the process up to. A consultant with a live brief answers both immediately. One who is mapping will be vague, not because they are being evasive but because there is genuinely nothing to be concrete about yet.

Take every call. Just know which one you are on, because it decides whether you are preparing for a process or building a relationship.

What to say when you are happy where you are

Never close the door and never pretend. “I am not looking, but tell me about it” costs nothing, keeps the relationship, and occasionally turns out to be the one you would move for. If it is genuinely not for you, offer two names. That is the currency of the whole market.

What not to do

  • Do not treat it as an offer. It is a conversation, and the great majority end without a process.
  • Do not use it as leverage internally. It travels, and it reads as manoeuvring rather than as being wanted.
  • Do not oversell your current scope. Everything you say will be checked, often by people who know.
  • Do not go quiet afterwards. A short thank-you keeps you in a mind that meets fifty people a month.

The honest limit

Calls arrive on somebody else's schedule, driven by somebody else's mandate. Pleasant as they are, a career built on waiting for them is a career where the timing is never yours.

Keep reading

Related

See it against your own companies

A short call, your target list, and an honest answer about whether this fits how you are running your search.