Executive career coaching

What executive career coaching can and cannot do

Good executive coaching is worth what it costs. It is also routinely bought to solve problems it structurally cannot solve, which is why so many executives finish a programme feeling they paid for encouragement.

What it does well

Clarity about what you want

The most underrated benefit. Many senior people are precise about everything except their own next decade, and an outside interrogator is genuinely better at this than a friend.

Narrative

Turning twenty years of accidents into a coherent story that a board can repeat. This is a real craft and most people are poor at it about themselves.

Negotiation and presence

Rehearsal with an experienced observer measurably improves how you handle a board conversation or a compensation discussion.

Discipline

A search is unstructured, discouraging and easy to avoid. Somebody expecting a progress report on Thursday changes behaviour.

What it cannot do

It cannot create access. A coach can help you decide that forty companies are right for you and can rehearse what you will say. They generally cannot tell you which of the forty is about to have a seat open, and they cannot introduce you to people they do not know. Access is the binding constraint in most senior searches, and coaching does not relieve it.

It cannot substitute for volume of real conversations. No amount of preparation replaces having been in front of twelve relevant people. Programmes that fill months with exercises are quietly converting search time into study time.

Coaching improves what happens once you are in the room. It rarely gets you into the room. Buy it for the first job, not the second.

The two questions that predict value

  • Is my problem clarity, or is it access? If you know exactly what you want and cannot get in front of anyone, a coach is the wrong purchase. If you are getting meetings and they are going nowhere, it is probably the right one.
  • What specifically will be different in twelve weeks? A good coach answers concretely — a positioning statement, a target list, three rehearsed conversations. A vague answer here predicts a vague engagement.

On price

Executive coaching ranges from a few thousand to well into five figures, and price correlates weakly with value. What correlates better is whether the coach has actually operated at the level you are targeting, and whether they will tell you something you do not want to hear in the first meeting.

Keep reading

Related

See it against your own companies

A short call, your target list, and an honest answer about whether this fits how you are running your search.